Apologies for my relative silence over recent days. A combination of being busy and suffering blogging fatigue from a dearth of good stories put my posting on hold.
Anyway, to the furore on MPs pay I thought I would offload my own thoughts. Apparently MPs might have their pay aligned with senior judges at over £100k pa. But a large portion of the public think MPs are paid too much already. So what do I think?...
1) MPs have to be paid. To have a situation whereby they vote on their own pay is silly on one hand as it places them in a tricky situation, but on the other it shows constituents their MPs true colours. In this sense it may be self limiting and restrain pay more than handing it to an independent body.
2) I personally don't feel one way or another over their level of pay. £60k is above the national average but not 'money for old rope' territory. MPs do tend to work for their money. It is generous but hardly sticking two fingers up at us minions.
So what would I do? Increase their pay to something higher, by all means, but cut their expenses commensurately so their is no net increase in cost to the taxpayer...
1) Cut their "additional costs allowance" that enable MPs to claim expenses for running a second home, and which leaves them free to keep the capital gain on this home. Either the second home should remain in public ownership to be sold when the MP retires/loses seat (or made available for another MP), OR MPs should be made to finance the entire cost out of their salary.
2) Pay mileage allowance at cost, not 57.7p
3) Capitalise their pensions and in future run a money purchase scheme, paying in to a private fund, and not leaving the taxpayer with a liability for those they have sacked. There should be no automatic final salary pension.
4) Scrap the "resettlement grant" for MPs who lose their seat which equates to 50-100% of salary. MPs should take out private 'unemployment' insurance if they so wish.
5) MPs should also have to produce receipts for all expenses as common practice in the private sector. They might also consider having to personally bear the cost of items below £50.
As for other expenses with regard to running an office etc, this is entirely reasonable. But as Milton Friedman said, there are 4 ways to spend money. Making MPs bear more costs personally will encourage them to minimise their costs as it will come out their own pocket. Providing their salaries are increased less then the cut in expenses then I have no problem with us paying a higher basic salary. Thus ends the lesson according to Vindico.